Will Smith’s Actual Offense on the Oscars

On the 2003 Academy Awards ceremony, host Steve Martin, a white comedian, made a not-so-funny gag geared toward Jennifer Lopez, born in New York to Puerto Rican dad and mom.

Lopez was sitting along with her beau of the time, Ben Affleck, a white Californian constructed like a light-heavyweight boxer (she could also be again with him now). You’ll perceive shortly why I’m being particular about their particulars.

You Can Take the Man Out of the Ghetto…

Watching the previous weekend’s Oscars altercation, I instantly questioned: What if Chris Rock, an African American comic, had cracked a gag on the expense of JLo and never Jada Pinkett Smith? After Martin’s joke, Lopez grinned politely, whereas Affleck, seated subsequent to her, was clearly unimpressed however pressured a transparently false smile.

The Yr the Oscars Went Black

READ MORE

However what if he had taken offense, like Will Smith, a black actor with the same construct to Affleck, did? If Affleck marched onto the stage and smacked Rock throughout the face, the state of affairs would have taken on a totally totally different dynamic. The headlines would have learn: White Actor Strikes Diminutive Black Host. Rock is 5 foot 7 inches and, in boxing phrases, appears to be like a few featherweight.

The media would have reacted otherwise, although how otherwise we’ll by no means know. One factor is for certain: The episode would have taken on a racial character.

Even because it was, Smith’s assault on Rock is loaded with racial implications, the obvious one being that he equipped white racists with sustenance. There may be an adage that “You possibly can take the person out of the ghetto however you possibly can’t take the ghetto out of the person.” Racists subscribe to this and infrequently cite the examples of O.J. Simpson and Mike Tyson, each African Individuals who grew to become conspicuously profitable and had more cash than they might depend. Each, of their other ways, imploded.

Smith hasn’t dedicated an offense comparable with rape or some other type of violent crime. And the LAPD has declared it won’t search prosecution. So, Smith’s contretemps is prone to stay that: a humiliation somewhat than against the law.

However let’s face it: Had it occurred in a unique context, the chances are the perpetrator of the offense could be arrested and charged. There could be no hassle discovering witnesses, both. Smith behaved like an ideal racial stereotype: hot-tempered, bull-headed, thuggish and, most significantly, incapable of controlling his feelings even in an atmosphere the place decorum prevailed. Even after Smith returned to his seat, he screamed obscenities at Rock, who lacked the wit to show the episode into one thing worthy of laughter. His was an unedifying exhibition of uncontrolled aggression.

Surprisingly, Smith was not ejected and, certainly, later picked up an award for finest actor.

Animating Masculinity

However pandering to inventory racist sorts was not Smith’s solely offense. His motion was borderline misogynistic, even perhaps enhancing the racial stereotype he’d dropped at life. Take into account if it was a case of Will being taken over by his emotion, seeing the look on his spouse’s face, in all probability below household stress along with her situation and snapping. Or a black man animating an anachronistic type of masculinity, traditionally related, although not completely, with black males. In any case, the amusing line was geared toward his spouse, Jada Pinkett Smith, who has alopecia, a situation that manifests within the partial or full absence of hair from areas of the physique the place it usually grows; baldness, in different phrases.

Couldn’t she have responded to the insult herself? She could have felt a extra dignified silence was the perfect coverage. However she may also have answered again with an equally acerbic comment. Or, if she had been moved to behave, Pinkett Smith might have administered the slap within the face herself. She’s about the identical dimension as Rock, so it wouldn’t have been the mismatch that really did happen. Since when do girls want their husbands, companions or male mates to maintain their enterprise? Jada appeared barely disgusted by Rock’s comment, however, up to now, her views on her husband’s violent habits aren’t recognized. Had she objected to it, we’d have absolutely came upon by now.

Since #MeToo gained momentum within the aftermath of the Harvey Weinstein case, the flagrant manipulation and abuse of girls by males — particularly highly effective ones — has develop into seen by way of the testimonies of numerous girls. We in all probability suspected for years that males get away with mistreating girls in additional methods than one. However #MeToo has successfully put the brake on this egregious historic observe.

What about males’s abuse of different males? I do know readers will suppose I’m stretching this too far, however absolutely males have the proper to not be coerced, harassed or intimidated too. Rock was solely doing his job — the custom at Oscar ceremonies is to “roast,” as Individuals name it. That’s, to topic friends to good-natured criticism. For a lot of, he could have overstepped the mark by making enjoyable of what’s, in spite of everything, a medical situation. However the casual guidelines about what constitutes good or dangerous style change 12 months by 12 months. Rock is not less than entitled to anticipate the individuals he insults can be acquainted sufficient with the customized that they take the ridicule within the spirit he intends.

Victims of Home Abuse

The LAPD’s intention to not pursue the case raises a ultimate problem. Ought to it’s vital for a complainant to press costs when an apparent assault has been dedicated? Rock is clearly embarrassed by the affair, and his failure to file a grievance presumably displays his need to have the incident rapidly forgotten. Numerous men and women, who’ve been victims of home abuse, don’t press costs. However their motivations are often very, very totally different. Typically, they’re pressured by their abuser or threatened with extra violence ought to they pursue costs.

The LAPD’s strategy to this appears head-in-the-sand. It would in all probability don’t have any penalties for Chris Rock and go away no harm, professionally or bodily (not less than he didn’t appear too badly harm). However victims of home abuse are by no means so lucky: their circumstances dictate that they typically imperil their very own security by giving proof. The LAPD’s choice won’t encourage them.

*[Ellis Cashmore is the author of “Kardashian Kulture.”]

The views expressed on this article are the creator’s personal and don’t essentially mirror Honest Observer’s editorial coverage.